The development of Exchange-Traded Funds (ETFs) has significantly reshaped the investment landscape, yet recent market events have raised concerns regarding the proper valuation and pricing strategies of these vehicles, particularly amidst extreme price fluctuationsIn the aftermath of the Chinese New Year, several currency ETFs have experienced dramatic price declines, bringing attention to the risks associated with high premium trading and market behavior driven by speculative activities.

As financial markets reopened following the holiday, a stark volatility emergedNotably, several currency ETFs saw their prices plummet sharply, some even hitting the daily limit downThis trend was not an isolated incident but rather a direct reaction to the unusual price hikes that occurred just before the holidayOn January 24, for instance, multiple currency ETFs, including the Guoshou Currency ETF and the Guotai Junan Currency ETF, saw gains exceeding 9% in just one day, leading to an effective market disconnect where trading prices began to stray noticeably from the actual net asset values (NAV) of the funds, hitting premium rates upwards of 10%. Following this unsustainable surge, the market cooled considerably post-holiday, with asset management firms promptly notifying investors of potential risks as a precautionary measure.

An in-depth analysis conducted by industry experts sheds light on this erratic behavior of currency ETFsOne important point raised is that some of these funds possess relatively smaller asset bases leading to insufficient liquidityConsequently, they become targets for speculative trading as short-term investors concentrate their capital in these products to capture swift profitsThis is exemplified by the instance of the Huatai Tiantian gold ETF, which saw its price soar to nearly 118 yuan before collapsing back to severe lows post-holiday—losses that effectively erased years of interest income in a single day.

Moreover, the structural dynamics related to the T+0 trading mechanism have further intensified the consequences of high premium trading

Advertisements

The T+0 structure allows investors to sell the purchased funds on the same day, tapping into immediate liquidity and flexibilityConsequently, it fuels a high frequency of trading, thus amplifying the overall volatility in an already unpredictable market environmentAs investors rushed to take positions to profit during the holiday season, the resulting demand drove prices further away from fundamental valuations, eventually spurring the rapid unwinding seen shortly thereafter.

Observing the distinct behaviors of cross-border ETFs introduces another layer of complexityUnlike their currency counterparts, cross-border ETFs have demonstrated a more sustained period of elevated premiums despite a general pullback in price trendsFor instance, on February 5, the Jiasir Germany ETF stalled at its daily limit down, trading volumes peaked at 22.2 billion yuan, reflecting a high turnover of 7.66 timesFollowing suit, on February 7, this ETF continued its downward trajectory, amassing a cumulative decline of 21%. Interestingly, despite this rate of decline, the premium ratio remained shockingly high—underlining a disconnect between the NAV and market price that raises uncomfortable questions about valuation integrity.

The ubiquitous nature of high premiums inherent to cross-border ETFs is likely influenced by a myriad of factors, including but not limited to limited foreign currency quotas, restrictions on Qualified Domestic Institutional Investor (QDII) fund subscriptions, growing demand for overseas investments, and the overall scarcity of the underlying assetsFor example, the Invesco Great Wall S&P Consumer Select ETF has reported premium rates surpassing 40%—a stark contrast to the modest growth of just 11% in its NAV over the preceding three months.

Market analysts, including those from Morningstar, emphasize the risks presented to investors as they navigate through these high premiumsShort-term speculators hoping to capitalize on the pricing gap might find themselves caught in a precarious situation if the market corrects itself and prices converge toward their true values

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements